AI NewsGo-to-marketReported

Semrush study finds AI Overviews now showing above almost every map pack

Semrush ran 480 local service searches. It found Google's AI Overviews now appear on nearly every one, often above the map pack.

AI News

Editorial2 min read

LinkedInX
Illustration of an AI answer replacing the map pack above a local search result

Why it mattersA business that ranks in the map pack can still be left out of the AI Overview. Owners need a second plan for the answer box.

A local business can rank in Google's map pack and still be missing from the AI Overview above it. Semrush ran a study of local service searches and found that result in most cases. Chris Shirlow at Semrush ran 480 searches by hand across 12 US markets of different sizes. The study covered 10 service types in each market.

Shirlow ran each query in two phrasings. One was short, like "plumber near me". The other was conversational, like "I need a plumber near me". He ran a first group of eight markets twice, and a second group of four markets twice.

What the study measured

Shirlow looked for two things on each search. The first was whether Google showed an AI Overview. The second was whether the AI Overview named the three businesses in the map pack. The numbers below are the ones the Semrush post reports.

The share of searches that showed an AI Overview grew in every round. Semrush says the first round of the eight-market group showed an AI Overview on 38 percent of the 160 searches. A later round of the eight-market group showed one on 66 percent. The four-market group went from 60 percent to 99 percent, which Shirlow gives as 79 of 80 searches.

Semrush says the conversational phrasing pulled an AI Overview more often. In the first pass of the eight-market group, 79 of 120 conversational searches showed an AI Overview. Only 29 of 120 short searches did. In a later pass, 105 of 120 conversational showed one, against 79 of 120 short.

The map pack and the AI Overview do not agree

Both the AI Overview and the map pack showed up on the same page in many searches. In those cases, Semrush says, the AI Overview named all three map pack businesses only 21 percent of the time. About 22 percent of AI Overviews named none of the three.

The businesses the AI Overview did name often had weak Google rankings. Semrush says 36 percent of them had no page-one ranking for the search. Only 29 percent ranked in the top three results.

Shirlow writes that the AI Overview sometimes replaced the map pack. In the final pass it showed business cards of its own instead.

The local-business owner has two problems to solve now. The first is what the business says about itself on third-party sites. The AI Overview is pulling names from there. The second is the home page. The ranking that earned the map pack does not carry the business into the AI answer above it. The money and the time that went into the map pack listing covers less of the page than it did.

Source

AI Overviews are taking over the map pack. Here's what I found by Chris Shirlow at Semrush.

Reported bySemrush

This item was written by an AI system from the linked source. Reveneau is responsible for what it publishes.

Share
LinkedInX
Start a project